What Your High Schooler Needs From You That They Will Never Ask For

High School Development  ·  Ages 15 to 18

What Your High Schooler Needs From You That They Will Never Ask For

The specific things teenagers need from parents during high school that they are developmentally unlikely to request, and how to provide them anyway

By Dr. Erica Buchholz, PhD  ·  Becoming Playful

Key Points

• High schoolers need things from parents that the individuation process makes it nearly impossible for them to ask for directly.
• The needs that go unvoiced are often the most important ones: unconditional regard, a regulated presence, honest modeling of adult life.
• What a teenager needs and what they ask for are often different things, and knowing the difference is some of the most important parenting knowledge available at this stage.
• Providing what they need without requiring them to ask for it is one of the most sophisticated parenting moves of the high school years.
• The things they never asked for are frequently the things they remember most clearly as adults.

They Do Not Ask Because They Cannot

The individuation process that defines adolescence is also a process that makes certain requests impossible. To ask for reassurance about your fundamental worth is to admit you need it, which feels inconsistent with the emerging adult identity. To ask for a parent to slow down the launch is to admit you are frightened of it. To ask for the kind of presence that younger children request openly requires a vulnerability that the developmental stage is actively working against.

So they do not ask. And the parents who provide what is needed anyway, without requiring a request, are doing some of the most important parenting of the high school years.

What They Need That They Will Not Ask For

Research on what teenagers retrospectively identify as most important from their parents during high school consistently surfaces several themes that are rarely requested directly. Unconditional positive regard, the clear and repeated communication that the teenager is loved and valued completely independent of any performance or outcome, is the most fundamental and the one most frequently received only implicitly, if at all. Teenagers who heard this clearly and often from a parent describe it as one of the most significant resources of their adolescence (Rogers, 1961; Steinberg, 2001).

What Retrospective Research ShowsLongitudinal research on what adults value most from their adolescent experience with parents identifies several consistent elements: knowing their parents were genuinely proud of who they were, not only what they achieved; having at least one parent they felt they could bring something genuinely difficult to; feeling that their parent's love was not contingent on their performance; and experiencing their parent as a full person with their own life and genuine interests, not only as a parenting role. Most of these are things the teenager would never have thought to ask for during high school (Steinberg, 2001).

A regulated parental presence, the nervous system stability that communicates that everything is manageable even when things are hard, is another need that teenagers cannot easily request but that research consistently identifies as significant. The parent who remains regulated through their teenager's crises, who communicates through their own state that the situation is survivable, is providing something the teenager's own underdeveloped regulatory system cannot provide for itself.

The things your teenager needs most from you right now are the things they will never ask for. The parent who provides them anyway, without being asked, is doing some of the most important work of these years.

The Specific Things Worth Providing

Explicit and repeated communication of unconditional love, separate from any performance: said often, said casually, said in ordinary moments without requiring reciprocity. Honest modeling of adult life, including the parts that are uncertain, difficult, and not yet resolved: a parent who allows their teenager to see them navigating genuine complexity teaches something that no advice can teach. Genuine delight in who the teenager is as a person, separate from what they are accomplishing: the parent who finds their teenager genuinely interesting, who laughs with them and notices them and is curious about their specific way of being in the world, communicates something about their fundamental worth that achievement-focused attention cannot.

And the open door: the consistent, ordinary, repeated communication that the door is always open, that nothing they could bring would close it, that the parent is available for whatever comes. Said enough times, across enough ordinary moments, this becomes a conviction the teenager carries into the situations where they most need it. They do not ask for it. They do not need to. It is there.

How to Provide What Was Not Asked ForSay "I love you" in passing, without drama or weight, not requiring it to be returned. Share something genuinely uncertain from your own life. Laugh at something they find funny. Ask about something they care about from real curiosity. Sit in the same room sometimes without an agenda. Notice something specific about who they are that has nothing to do with what they are doing. These are ordinary things. They are also the things people remember.

Action Steps

1Say "I love you" often, without requiring anything in return.

In passing. Casually. Not as consolation after difficulty or as bookending of difficult conversations. As a regular, ordinary feature of the relationship. The frequency and the casualness are what make it feel unconditional.

2Model honest adult life, including the uncertain parts.

"I am genuinely not sure how to handle something I am navigating right now" is more valuable to a teenager facing the unknown of their own future than any advice about how to handle hard things. The model is the teaching.

3Find your teenager genuinely interesting and let them see that.

Specific, genuine curiosity about who they are and how they think, expressed in ordinary moments without an evaluative frame, communicates something about their worth that achievement-focused attention cannot reach.

4Stay regulated through whatever they bring.

The parent who remains settled through their teenager's genuine difficulties communicates that the situation is manageable. That communication is more valuable in many moments than any specific response to the content of the difficulty.

5Repeat the open door message across ordinary moments.

"There is nothing you could bring to me that would make me stop being in your corner" said often enough, in calm ordinary moments, becomes a conviction rather than a statement. It does not require a crisis to be said. Say it now.

Summary

High schoolers need things from parents that the individuation process makes impossible to request directly: unconditional love communicated often and casually, honest modeling of adult life including its uncertainty, genuine delight in who they are as people separate from what they are accomplishing, regulated parental presence through their difficulties, and the repeated open-door message that nothing would close the relationship. Providing these without requiring a request is among the most sophisticated and most important parenting of the high school years. They will not ask. The parent who provides them anyway is building the resource the teenager will draw on long after they have launched.

Frequently Asked Questions

My teenager is very private and does not seem to want anything from me. Do these things still matter?

Yes. The private teenager is not a teenager who does not need the relationship. They are a teenager who has difficulty showing that they do. The unconditional love, the open door, the regulated presence: these matter precisely because they do not require the teenager to perform need in order to receive them.

What if I genuinely do not find my teenager interesting right now?

This is honest and more common than parents acknowledge. Finding something specific, a particular way they think, a particular thing they care about, a particular quality they show up with, is more achievable than general interest in a person you are currently finding difficult. Start small and specific.

My teenager pushes back when I say positive things. How do I keep saying them?

Say them anyway. The pushback is often the adolescent defensive response to something that lands but that they are not ready to show has landed. 'I still see it' said calmly after the pushback is enough. The consistent repetition across many moments is what eventually produces the internal shift.

I am not naturally emotionally expressive. How do I say these things?

Find the format that is authentic to you rather than performing one that is not. A note. A text. A brief observation in the car. The authenticity matters more than the eloquence. A parent who finds their own genuine way to communicate unconditional love is more credible than one who is performing warmth they do not feel.

How do I know if what I am providing is actually being received?

Often you do not, until much later. The research on retrospective accounts of adolescence is full of adults describing things their parents did or said that they had no idea were being received at the time. Trust the process and continue. The reception is happening even when the surface shows nothing.

Sources

Rogers, C. R. (1961). On becoming a person. Houghton Mifflin.

Steinberg, L. (2001). We know some things: Parent-adolescent relationships in retrospect and prospect. Journal of Research on Adolescence, 11(1), 1-19.

Siegel, D. J. (2013). Brainstorm: The power and purpose of the teenage brain. Tarcher/Penguin.

If you want support knowing how to show up for your high schooler in the ways that matter most, Dr. Erica works with parents of teenagers one-on-one. Visit becomingplayful.com.

Visit Becoming Playful